Bad Software Buying Habits

Solution Explorers on December 1st, 2009. Under Problems

The software doesn't work as promised!!

Who’s to blame for a disappointing business software purchase experience – the buyer or seller(s)?

Before we go any further, I want to suggest that this question is just too relative to accurately answer – i.e. there are many sellers (vendors) that lack integrity but there are also many buyers that are poor planners. More often than not, the responsibility is a shared one. However, as a buyer, it’s ultimately your money and you have to “live with it” once the purchase is made.

Rather than trying to answer such a relative question let’s instead take a close look at some Bad Software Buying Habits. My last post – Components of a Good Software Needs Analysis – certainly ties in well here as well. Do any of these resonate with you?

1) Failure to document existing issues and system requirements.

2) Purchase the system based on pre-evaluation budget guesswork or some pre-defined grant award that’s about to expire.

3) Referral from a friend, close associate, or like-kind entity without an understanding of your needs.

4) Getting “hooked” by a skilled salesperson, slick collateral, a “sexy” user-interface, or a finely tuned “dog-and-pony show.”

5) Paying 100% – that’s bad enough – but even worse without requiring a detailed work-scope (aka Letter of Engagement) document that’s signed by both parties.

6) Choosing the lowest bidder and still minimizing services.

7) Selecting the vendor with the stamina to “hang around long enough” through all of your delays or the vendor “in the right place at the right time.”

In summary, proper planning is key to a rewarding buying experience. As you document your system requirements and selection criteria BEFORE contacting software vendors then you will position your company to not only select the software system that meets your exact needs but also be a good steward of your financial and time resources.

I’m sure you too have witnessed some Good and Bad habits. What’s been your experience?

Bookmark and Share
  • Gosh Keith, I think one that comes to mind in my experience is having the management team select a tool for the masses to use without the actual users getting any say. This goes hand in hand with your #1 issue. Another problem I've seen which is an extension of your #4, is purchasing a software solution that has a proprietary back end. In particular, a back end that does not allow for simple exports to Excel, Access, SQL, etc... Products need to always have the ability to "kick" out data to other formats. Good article!
  • Brad - you're spot on in these obsersations. Keep an eye on the latter one as many buyers and the software technology industry appears to be moving toward hosted, Saas, web-based solutions. These have many upsides I believe. One drawback it appears in the Saas world, however, is that most of these providers select the database; and as you indicated it is proprietary. In fact, I'll give some thought now to writing a post outline some differences between hosted, Web-based, Saas, and on-premise client/server applications. Thanks!
  • Excellent post, and yes, the 7 points above can all lead to software selection disaster--or at the least, serious and long-term IT headaches. Another critical factor in the software selection process is user buy-in as a component of change management. Even if you select a "best-fit" enterprise system, failure to obtain user buy-in at the selection stage will result in low user adoption rates, pervasive workarounds, and epidemics of information silos. See my posting at http://blog.technologyevaluati... for more disasters in the making!

    All the best, and thanks for an insightful posting.

    David Clark
    Managing Editor
    Technology Evaluation Centers
    "Enterprise Software Evaluations: Simply Decide"
  • David - what an excellent addition. One of my objectives as I help businesses with effective evaluations is to engage those most impacted by the application change early in the process so that their concerns and opinions are heard. Thanks for commenting.
blog comments powered by Disqus